A lazy schmuck’s guide to making old-fashioned dry martinis

The first time I had a martini I was 21, on my first business-class flight (I wasn’t paying), and I ordered one from the hostess because I thought it was the sophisticated thing to do. To this day I remember my disappointment when I was served a glass of something that tasted like it came straight from the plane’s fuel tank: industrial, toxic and not for human consumption. The olive wasn’t much better.
At that point I learnt three key things:
- I’m not James Bond
- Not to order cocktails on planes
- A poorly made martini can taste disastrous.
It took me years after that before I fell in love with martinis again, mainly after I had a great one at the Gin Palace in Melbourne, but even so I just couldn’t make them at home. I consulted books and websites, bought enough gin and vermouth to become a 1920s bootlegger and yet every martini I made didn’t taste a whole lot better than my first airplane-made one.
Yet when a friend of mine recently brought me a giant duty free bottle of Christies gin from New Zealand (a brilliant gin that’s made with the native NZ botanicals horopito and kawakawa. Unfortunately, however, I can’t find it anywhere in Sydney) I tried something new out of desperation – and it worked.
Actually, I tried something old: I went back to the original recipe for a dry martini of using two parts gin to one part dry vermouth – and now I’m obsessed again.
These days the 2 to 1 ratio isn’t dry at all, considering how little vermouth most people put in their drinks – sometimes when I order a martini I’m simply served gin in a glass with a mere hint of vermouth, which can work ok if they’re using fantastic gin but still, to me, defeats the purpose.
The other gripe I have with martinis I order elsewhere is the quality of olives used, so I take delight in using great olives that are stuffed with anchovies (an idea which I shamelessly stole from the Gin Palace’s 1951 martini). Incidentally, the 1951 martini also uses the trick of rinsing Cointreau around the inside of the glass first, but I’m still not sophisticated enough to do that at home.
Another thing to remember, of course, is to chill the martini glass first by filling it with ice. Also, if you do shake your gin and vermouth (and remember to add lots of ice to the shaker as well) then double strain it as you pour it into the glass so you don’t have ice shards floating on the surface (although I’m usually too lazy to do this).
As for whether martinis should be shaken or stirred: most people in the know seem to believe gin martinis should be stirred, not shaken, but as a hypochondriac who believes everything I read, I prefer to shake mine after reading this article in the British Medical Journal.
For those too lazy to follow the link, the gist is that the boffins discovered that shaken gin martinis are healthier for you than stirred ones, since they’re better at deactivating hydrogen peroxide – which apparently is a good thing. I myself like the fact that it makes sure the drink is ice cold, although a knowledgeable bartender friend of mine assures me you can get equally cold martinis by stirring.
The BMJ article also talks a bit about James Bond, who – especially in the movies – popularised the idea of vodka martinis, which I personally don’t approve of (when writing an article about martinis I feel it’s de rigeur to sound like a snob). Even though vodka purists tell me different vodkas have different tastes and mouth feels – and I’m sure they’re right – there’s something fantastic about a great gin’s botanical goodness that to me is an essential part of a martini (I think the next gin I’m going to buy myself will be Hendricks).
But, as I said, I’m no expert. If you have any martini tips or experiences then feel free to leave a comment below:
Related posts:


Hey,
Just wanted to let you know that I enjoy barzine and regularly look it up to educate myself on the happening places in Sydney. I hope you realize you are providing a really useful, fun service and in a format with content thats a pleasure to read.
Thank you and please keep up the good work!
Tige
Hi Tige: Thank you so much! I really appreciate that!
Excellent guide for closet Martini lovers. Well done, great website too! I’m in the mood for one right now actually… the olives stuffed with anchovies is a great idea too.